The pizza here is actually really good. Best in the neighborhood for sure. Too bad they don't do evening or late night deliveries.

I happened to be in the neighborhood and I saw this pizza spot. I wanted to get a slice of pizza, but I noticed they also had hot food, so I decided to get the hot food. It was amazing, very delicious, and at a reasonable price. If you guys are in the neighborhood, you need to check out this spot. It also has healthy food, so don't underestimate it, it's more than just pizza.

I adore this place. It’s a cozy and calm haven on a gritty block of Sunset Park near the Brooklyn Army Terminal. The cooks prepare all the food fresh from scratch everyday, and the portions are very generous. If you like meat pizza, this is the place! But the best thing of all about Cafe 58 is Nick—the hard-working owner of the shop. He’s a real sweetheart.

This place does not only have excellent food, but the service is phenomenal. The owner himself greets every person as if he knew them for a lifetime. Such a gentleman and a scholar. I’m glad I have a place like this close to my job where I can eat.

Great family run pizzeria and a variety of preprepared food and salads. Local atmosphere. Clean bathroom.

Cafe 58 Pizza and Grill is an absolute gem nestled in Sunset Park Brooklyn. From the moment you step in, the inviting ambiance and friendly staff make you feel right at home. The aroma of freshly baked pizzas wafting through the air immediately whets your appetite. Their pizzas are truly exceptional! The crust is perfectly crispy yet delightfully chewy, and the toppings are generous and flavorful. The variety of options caters to every taste bud - from classic Margherita to adventurous specialty pizzas that never disappoint. What sets Cafe 58 apart is not just the incredible food, but also the warm and attentive service. The staff members go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience, making you feel like part of their family. Don't miss out on their delightful grill options too! Whether it's the succulent grilled chicken or the perfectly seasoned burgers, each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. Overall, Cafe 58 Pizza and Grill is a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts and foodies alike. It's a place where delicious food meets exceptional service, creating an unforgettable dining adventure.

Great food, very good customer service. This place was very peaceful and it's greatly appreciated. Excellent!!!

Great food served by super friendly staff. And the prices are fair.